Market Order or Limit Order
A market order takes the book price; a limit order sets your price but may fill only partially.
In this article
The first brokerage screen asks an unexpected question: order type. The two main answers offer opposite guarantees. The market order takes what the book offers: execution is near-certain, but the price is not guaranteed, since the book can move between click and fill. On a liquid security with a one-cent spread, the risk is measured in fractions of a cent, and simplicity wins. The limit order reverses the promise: the price will never exceed the limit, but execution becomes conditional, sometimes partial, if the security drifts away. It is the tool for visible spreads and volatile days. The time of day matters too: spreads widen at the open and the close, and mid-session costs less. Funds holding foreign assets trade better when their underlying market is open. This article explains the two mechanisms with examples, gives simple rules by security liquidity and points out the moments to avoid.
Look at the book before choosing the order type
The choice between a market order and a limit order is decided by looking at two figures: the best bid and the best ask at the moment of the order. Their gap is the implicit cost of immediate execution. On a heavily traded security, that spread is a few cents, and the market order fills at a price practically identical to the displayed one. On a thinly traded security, the spread can reach several percent, and the same market order fills considerably further away. The book, not the order type, determines which of the two fits.
Check depth, not just price
The displayed price holds only for the quantity available at that price. A market order for a thousand shares on a security where only two hundred are offered at the best price fills in successive tranches, at rising prices. You discover it only afterward. This mechanism explains most disappointing fills on small-cap securities and thinly traded funds. Look at the book's depth before sending a large order. When depth is thin, break the order up rather than sending it as one block.
Accept what a limit does not guarantee
A limit order guarantees the price, never the execution. A limit set slightly below the market may never be reached, and the security may rise without you: the cost of that protection is the risk of staying out. A partial fill is also possible. It leaves an order half filled and, depending on the broker, commission on each portion. The choice comes down to a simple question: which costs you more, paying a few cents extra or not getting the security? The answer depends on the transaction, not on a general preference.
Be extra careful when liquidity is thin
Three situations widen spreads and make market orders risky: the session's first and last minutes, thinly traded securities, and periods of high volatility or announcements. In those conditions, a market order can fill far from the last posted price, with no recourse. As a precaution, use a limit order by default in all three cases, with the limit set slightly beyond the current price. You get the fill while capping the slippage. Be equally cautious with an order placed outside trading hours, since the open can gap noticeably from the close.
Quebec scenario
First ETF purchase for a speech therapist in Saint-Tite, and a first brokerage screen: order type, a menu she was not expecting. Her position is modest, $5,000 in a heavily traded Canadian ETF, but she wants to understand the two main options before clicking. The market order takes what the book offers at that instant: execution is near-certain, but the price is not guaranteed, since the book can move between the click and the fill. The limit order reverses the promise: the price will never exceed her limit, but execution becomes conditional, sometimes partial, if the security drifts away. For her liquid ETF, the gap between the best bid and the best ask is one cent, so a market order risks almost nothing. She sees it live: purchase filled at the displayed price, 100 units, done. Her advisor shows her the exception the following month, on a thinly traded sector ETF. The spread there reaches thirty cents, and a volatile morning can widen it further. The limit order, placed mid-spread, fills in two stages over twenty minutes and saves about $18 on the same position size. Her beginner's rule has held since: market orders for liquid securities on calm days, limit orders as soon as the spread is visible to the naked eye, and never an order launched in the minutes right after the open.
Checklist
- Check the bid-ask spread before the order
- Use market orders on liquid securities in calm sessions
- Use limits as soon as the spread is visible
- Place the limit mid-spread
- Accept possible partial execution
- Avoid the open and the close
- Trade foreign funds during their market's hours
- Verify the fill received
- Note the rules in your brokerage notebook
The questions we get
A question about your situation?
A Quebec broker answers, with no commitment.
Read next
// Investments
Asset Allocation or Product Selection: Decide in the Right Order
Set the goal, horizon and loss capacity first, then the target weights: products come last.
// Investments
Currency Conversion in a Brokerage Account
Check the currency of the investment and account, then the markup the broker adds to the exchange rate.
// Investments
TFSA or RRSP: Choose by Goal and Tax Rate
Choose between TFSA and RRSP based on the goal, the withdrawal horizon and your current and future tax rates.