Non-Sufficient Funds Payment: Understand Fees on Both Sides
A returned payment costs on both sides: account fees and payee fees. Check the date the debit is presented.
In this article
A payment without funds is billed on both sides at once: an insufficient-funds fee at your account, a returned-payment fee at the creditor. A single incident easily passes ninety dollars. The creditor's agreement often provides for a sequel: an automatic retry within days, which doubles the bill if the account has not been refilled in time. Repeated incidents can also be reported. The cause is almost always a processing order: the large outflows present the same day as a pay with no guaranteed hour. The fixes last: move withdrawals to a few days after the pay lands (a simple form at most creditors), keep a permanent cushion in the account and turn on a balance alert. This article details the fees on both sides, the retry mechanics and the calendar realignment that solves the problem at its source.
Find the date the debit actually presents
A payment refused for insufficient funds turns on a precise moment, rarely the one people assume. A cheque handed over Monday may present Thursday. A preauthorized debit announced for the first of the month sometimes presents the day before or after, depending on business days. An online bill payment processes the same day, but a transfer can take two. Work this out for your recurring charges by noting the debit's real date rather than the announced one. You will see where they land at the same time as your paydays, which explains most refusals.
Count the fees on both sides
A payment without funds costs twice. The institution charges a refusal fee, often between forty and fifty dollars. The payee charges its own returned-payment fee, generally between twenty-five and fifty dollars, and sometimes adds a late fee since the payment was not received on time. A refused two-hundred-dollar cheque can therefore cost ninety dollars, forty-five percent of the amount. People rarely do this addition. It explains why a one-off two-hundred-dollar overdraft, at a few dollars of interest, is almost always cheaper than a refusal.
Anticipate the automatic retry
Many preauthorized debits are presented again automatically after a refusal, often three to five days later, sometimes without notice. If the account is still empty, that second attempt produces a second refusal and a second pair of fees, doubling the bill for a single payment. After a first refusal, ask the payee whether the debit will return and when. One call is enough. You can then fund the account in time or agree to pay another way. Passively waiting for the second refusal is the most common way to double the cost.
Order the payments to prevent repetition
An isolated refusal is an accident. A refusal every month is a calendar problem. Align debit dates with your pay dates rather than with the first of the month: most providers accept this on simple request. Group the debits two days after each pay rather than leaving them scattered, and the risk window disappears. Fees already charged can sometimes be contested. The institution often waives them for a first incident on an account in good standing. Make the request promptly, politely, and once. If refusals keep coming back, the month's committed outflows exceed what lands in the account before them, and no date change fixes that for long. That problem belongs in the budget, not in the calendar, and the fees are just the price the account charges for pointing it out.
Quebec scenario
The mortgage debit of a couple in Portneuf presents on the 1st of the month. The pay, also deposited on the 1st, arrives a few hours too late that month. The payment bounces and the bill lands on both sides: $45 in account fees for insufficient funds, then $48 charged by the lender for the refused payment. Two separate fees for a single incident, $93 in all. The lender's agreement holds another surprise: an automatic retry will happen within three days, and a second bounce would double the bill and trigger a report. The couple tops up the account right away, then goes after the cause. The problem is a processing order: all the large outflows present on the 1st, the same day as a pay with no guaranteed hour. The lender agrees to move the debit to the 3rd, with a form filed, and the insurance follows to the 5th. A $500 cushion goes into the account as a permanent buffer, and a balance alert completes the setup. What the couple takes away: a payment without funds costs twice, once per side, and prevention often comes down to a simple change of date.
Checklist
- Add both sides' fees on a bounce
- Check the planned automatic retry
- Refill immediately after an incident
- Confirm the retry date with the creditor
- Request the withdrawals be moved
- Align the outflows after the pay lands
- Keep a permanent cushion in the account
- Install a balance alert
- Watch the file if the incident repeats
The questions we get
A question about your situation?
A Quebec broker answers, with no commitment.
Read next
// Banking
Overdraft Protection: Fees, Interest and Alternatives
Compare the monthly or per-use fees and the interest on the overdraft with the available alternatives.
// Banking
Bank Draft or Certified Cheque for a Large Payment
Know whether the funds are withdrawn or set aside, and how the recipient will verify the payment’s authenticity.
// Banking
Choose a Chequing Account for Your Actual Transactions
Count your actual debits, transfers and withdrawals in a typical month before choosing a chequing package.