High-Interest Savings Accounts: Compare Net Return
Compare the regular rate, not the headline rate, and check how often interest is calculated to know the real net return.
In this article
Savings accounts get compared by headline rates, but the real return is decided elsewhere. First there is the regular rate, the one that remains after the promotions: a showcase rate lasting a few months weighs little across twelve if the base rate is weak. Then there are the conditions: how often interest is calculated and paid, transfer fees, withdrawal limits, minimum balance. Each one can erode the advertised gap between two offers. Taxation completes the picture outside a TFSA, since tax on interest cuts the net return at your marginal rate. And for savings tied to a dated goal, access to the funds matters as much as the rate: a three-day transfer can complicate a deposit on a house. This article lines up the criteria in useful order (regular rate, conditions, tax, access) and offers a twelve-month calculation that separates offers better than any ad.
Look for the rate that will survive
Savings accounts are sold on headline rates of three or four months, but you live with their regular rate. To compare honestly, project a full twelve months: the promotion for its duration, then the base rate for the rest, set against your current account running uninterrupted. A spectacular showcase rate resting on a very low regular rate often loses that comparison against a stable, average account. Also check the regular rate from time to time. Institutions adjust it quietly, upward to attract customers and downward while counting on inertia. A five-minute reminder each quarter is enough. Savers' inertia is exactly the business model that reminder defeats.
Verify the interest mechanics
Two accounts at the same rate do not necessarily pay the same amount. Look first at the calculation frequency: interest computed on the daily balance pays every dollar every day, while a calculation on the monthly minimum balance penalizes any mid-month withdrawal. Look next at the payment frequency, monthly or otherwise, which triggers compounding. Look finally at the rate conditions: some accounts require a minimum balance to pay the displayed rate, or pay in tiers by amount. These rules, stated in the account's terms, create real gaps between offers that seem like twins. The rate line draws the eye, but the lines after it decide the amount.
Count the fees, limits and tax
The displayed return is gross. The real return comes after three subtractions. First, fees: billed outgoing transfers, a limited number of free withdrawals, sometimes inactivity charges. Every dollar of fees cancels a fraction of a point of rate. Second, limits: daily transfer ceilings, delays between institutions, constraints that stay invisible until the day they bite. Third, tax, outside a TFSA: interest joins taxable income and is taxed at the marginal rate, so a four percent return nets barely more than two and a half for many taxpayers. Compare accounts at equal structure, then. The tax-shelter question, whether or not you have TFSA room, comes before the rate question.
Guarantee access on the project's date
Savings tied to a dated goal (down payment, trip, project) must be available on the day, and you should test availability before you need it. Measure the real delay of a transfer to your chequing account: instant internally, one to three business days between institutions, with delays that grow over weekends and holidays. A deposit required on a Friday cannot wait for a transfer launched Thursday evening. Build the repatriation of the funds into the project calendar: the money returns to the chequing account a few days before the deadline, sacrificing a little interest for certainty. The market's best rate never compensates for funds that are unavailable at the precise moment the project demands them.
Quebec scenario
A pharmacist in Boucherville sees an ad promoting 5.5% on a savings account and nearly moves her house fund there. Reading the terms, she finds the conditions: 5.5% for four months on new deposits only, then back to a regular rate of 1.7%. Her current account pays 3.9% with no conditions. She compares twelve months on $40,000: the promotion yields about $1,186 in year one ($733 during the promotion, then $453 at the regular rate), against $1,560 for her current account. She also checks how often interest is calculated and paid, daily in both cases, the absence of fees and withdrawal limits, and the taxation of interest outside a TFSA, identical on both sides. One last criterion, often forgotten: immediate access to the funds when the time comes to make an offer on a house, because a three-day transfer can complicate a deposit. She stays where she is and puts a quarterly reminder in her calendar to recheck the regular rate.
Checklist
- Compare regular rates, not headline rates
- Check how often interest is calculated and paid
- Read the fees, withdrawal limits and minimum balance
- Calculate the net return outside a TFSA
- Verify the real transfer delay to chequing
- Confirm access to the funds on the project's date
- Compare over a full twelve months
- Avoid chasing a three-month showcase rate
- Recheck the regular rate every quarter
The questions we get
A question about your situation?
A Quebec broker answers, with no commitment.
Read next
// Banking
Avoid Bank Fees Without Tying Up Too Much Cash
Compare the fee waiver with the return lost on the tied-up minimum balance before accepting the condition.
// Banking
Promotional Savings Rates: Check the Period and Eligible Balance
Note the promotion dates and check whether the rate applies to new deposits only or to the whole balance.
// Banking
Choose a Chequing Account for Your Actual Transactions
Count your actual debits, transfers and withdrawals in a typical month before choosing a chequing package.